Basis | Mutual Funds | Alternative Investment Fund (AIF) | Portfolio Investment Services (PMS) |
Meaning | Pooled investment vehicles
|
Privately pooled investment vehicles | Personalised investment service where a portfolio is managed separately for each investor/client. |
Regulation Authorities | SEBI (Mutual Funds) Regulations, 1996 | SEBI AIF Regulations,2012 | SEBI (Portfolio Managers) Regulations, 2020 |
Minimum Investment | This is as low as ₹500 with SIP | Minimum investment is ₹1 Cr. For Angel Funds, it is ₹25 lakh.
| ₹50 lakh minimum |
Investor Base | Retail Investors | HNIs, Institutional Investors, Family Offices | HNIs, Ultra-HNIs seeking personalised portfolio |
Diversification | High, across various asset classes. | Focused, often sector-specific | Limited to chosen portfolio stocks based on the investor's profile. |
Risk & Liquidity | High risk with daily NAV & Redemption | Moderate, typically close-ended with a lock-in period. | High risk; no lock-in, but the portfolio is concentrated and linked to market volatility |
Fee Structure | Mutual Funds generally charge management fees based on AUM. | AIFs typically follow a performance-based fee structure. | Fixed management fee (2%+) and sometimes performance-linked. |
Investment Restriction | Mutual funds must keep 95% of their funds invested in stock market instruments; hence cannot hold cash. | AIFs have no such restrictions, giving fund managers the flexibility to hold cash or invest in various funds. | Mostly listed securities, bonds, and structured products |
Investment Scope | Restricted to investing primarily in listed companies on the mainboard, such as large-cap, small-cap, and micro-cap stocks. | AIFs offer broader investment opportunities, investing in startups, SMEs, real estate, social impact funds, and even complex investments like F&O.
| Limited to listed securities, custom to the investor’s mandate. |
Hurdle Rate | In mutual funds, there is no specific hurdle rate; it depends on the investment objective.
| There are specific hurdle rates, often between 6-12%. Warren Buffett and Mohnish Pabrai have 6% hurdle rate, Most of the Funds have an 8-10% hurdle rate And a few aggressive funds go up to 12%. | No formal hurdle rate, depends on PMS strategy. |
Profit sharing | There is no profit-sharing model in Mutual Funds.
| AIFs usually follow an "80:20 profit-sharing rule", where 80% of profits go to investors and 20% to the fund managers.
| No direct profit-sharing; returns accrue to clients. |
Foreign Investments | Foreign investments are harder to do, as it requires more regulatory licenses(FPI). | AIFs have more relaxed foreign investments. A significant portion of investments in AIFs comes from foreign investors. | Possible but limited, requires approvals |
Suitability | Retail investors seeking and generally looking steady, diversified, low-cost exposure. | Sophisticated investors looking for higher alpha from unique opportunities alternatives (SMEs, startups, alternative assets) | HNIs seek tailored portfolios aligned with personal risk-return profiles. |